Posts
Kerala has often been portrayed as a state grappling with severe alcohol and drug abuse. However, recent figures from central government agencies paint a contrasting picture, suggesting that these perceptions are not only exaggerated but also potentially misleading. This article delves into the latest available data to debunk the myth and explore the possible motivations behind such propaganda.
Alcohol Consumption in Kerala: Challenging the Narrative
The notion of Kerala being a top alcohol-consuming state is frequently challenged by official statistics. According to the National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5), conducted recent years, alcohol consumption among men (19.9%) and women (0.2%) aged 15 years and above in Kerala is notably lower than in several other Indian states. To provide a broader context, let's consider figures from other states as well:
Arunachal Pradesh reports significantly higher rates with 52.7% for men and 24.2% for women.
Odisha, while showing a decrease in alcohol consumption among men, still has a higher rate than Kerala at 28.8% for men, and a notably increasing rate among women at 4.3%.
Madhya Pradesh shows a considerable alcohol consumption rate as well, although specific NFHS-5 figures need to be further verified for exact comparison.
Uttar Pradesh, often compared to Kerala in terms of population and socio-economic factors, also has a comparable alcohol consumption rate with 18.7% among men and 1.3% among women, similar or more to Kerala's figures when considering gender distribution.
Even in Gujarat, a state with prohibition laws, 5.8% of men and 0.6% of women report alcohol consumption.
Furthermore, the 'Magnitude of Substance Use in India, report by the Union Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, which remains a key source for national level data, indicates that Kerala's alcohol consumption rate of 12.4% is below the national average of 14.6%. Several states, including Chhattisgarh (35.6%), Tripura (34.7%), and Punjab (28.5%), demonstrate considerably higher alcohol consumption rates.
While more recent comprehensive national surveys comparable to NFHS-5 and the Magnitude report are still awaited, the existing data strongly suggests that Kerala's alcohol consumption is not disproportionately high compared to other states in India.
Drug Use in Kerala: Addressing Concerns with Proactive Measures
While precise state-wise data on drug consumption is less readily available in national surveys, it is crucial to acknowledge and address the concerns surrounding substance abuse in Kerala. The state government has been proactive in launching initiatives to combat drug use. The 'Vimukthi' anti-narcotics campaign is a notable example, focusing on raising awareness and combating drug abuse, particularly among young people. The Kerala government has actively sought public cooperation to protect future generations from the dangers of drugs.
Dispelling the Propaganda: Unmasking the Motivations
The persistent portrayal of Kerala as a state with exceptionally high alcohol and drug abuse rates appears to be a myth unsupported by current central government data. This raises the critical question: who benefits from perpetuating this false narrative?
Several factors could contribute to this propaganda:
Outdated Perceptions: Negative stereotypes about Kerala may be rooted in older data or anecdotal evidence that does not reflect the current reality.
Political Agendas: Spreading misinformation can be a tactic used by political rivals to undermine the ruling dispensation and tarnish the state's image for political gain.
Competitive Interests: In a federal system, states compete for resources, investments, and positive national attention. Negative portrayals could be strategically amplified to disadvantage Kerala in this competition.
Sensationalism: Media outlets may sometimes prioritize sensational stories over factual reporting, leading to an overemphasis on negative aspects like drug use, even if data does not support an exaggerated narrative.
It is essential to critically evaluate claims about Kerala and substance abuse, relying on verified, up-to-date data from reputable sources. Unfounded narratives can stigmatize the state and distract from the real efforts being made to address social issues.
Conclusion: Fact-Based Understanding is Crucial
Current central government figures do not support the notion that Kerala is a leading state in alcohol and drug consumption. In fact, data indicates consumption rates are lower than in many other states. Moreover, Kerala is actively engaged in addressing substance abuse through dedicated campaigns and government initiatives. It is therefore imperative to base our understanding on factual data and exercise caution against narratives that are not supported by evidence. By doing so, we can foster a more accurate and balanced perception of Kerala and its societal challenges.
It's important to note that while the data dispels the myth of Kerala being exceptionally high in substance abuse, it does not negate the reality of substance abuse issues within the state, which require continuous attention and effective interventions.
